Living Between the Mommy Wars

Jody Fernando


Subscribe to the Junia Project Blog

Get content on biblical equality straight to your inbox. And get our free guide: 5 Pillars of Biblical Equality

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


rosie and child

The moment a child is born, the mother is also born. She never existed before. The woman existed, but the mother, never. A mother is something absolutely new. – Rajneesh

When I was pregnant, a friend of mine told me that her mother hadn’t been much into babies.  She chuckled a bit as she recounted her mom’s comment, “I didn’t even like you until you were three.”  In the midst of the mystery and sentiment of pregnancy, I had a hard time following her mother’s thinking.  I mean, life was growing inside me – precious, beautiful, mysterious life! How could someone not like a baby?!?  While I chuckled at the sentiment, I couldn’t quite grasp it, that is, until one actually showed up in my arms.

I suspect my initial inability to understand had something to do with the fact that I had not yet lost years of sleep, been puked on multiple times, gained over 50 pounds, spent months nauseated, endured bouts of mastitis, or tried to reason with a screaming two-year-old.  I had not yet encountered the daunting challenge of quieting a screaming baby on a 20 hour flight, keeping little fingers out of electrical sockets, or short-changing conversations to clean up the box of cereal dumped on the floor. To put it simply, I had no idea what was about to hit me. Thank God.  While I’d never reverse the gifts motherhood gives, I have to admit that my journey has been a bit slow-in-the-making.  Even though I was fairly well prepared for the nuts-and-bolts of diaper changing and stroller assembly, I had no clue how motherhood would reshape my identity. 

For a variety of reasons, it made the most sense for me to stay home full-time when our first child was born.  I was ok with this decision for a while.  But then I started to get a bit – *gasp* – bored.  I’d call my husband every hour at work.  I’d watch Jerry Springer.  In extremely slow moments, I’d even resort to cleaning.

Then God did something gracious.  My husband accepted a job in which he took a 25% pay cut.  The loss of salary required me to work – not for luxuries but necessities.  Even with the budget stripped to the bone, we couldn’t pay the bottom line bills.  So, I got a job, and to my great surprise, I LOVED it.  I’d practically dance out of the house.  It was only about ten hours a week, but those ten hours brought a whole new level of sanity to my diaper-changing, pacifier-finding, baby-weary brain.

I don’t share this to denigrate full-time stay-at-home moms; just to show that it wasn’t working for me.  (If anything, it gives me more respect for women who flourish under the stresses of staying home full-time.)  As the years have passed, I’ve realized that part of my struggle in the early years of my children’s lives was that I was forging a brand new identity.  I was changing in ways I’d never changed before, and it was hard.  It was definitely a between time for me – between carefree young woman and responsible parent, between pretty young thing and chubby young mother, between barely awake and half asleep – and it took time to settle into.

On top of these pieces, as a part-time working mom I’m also a professional in-betweener.  I pick up the kids from school with the stay-at-home moms and bemoan office politics with the working ones.  I volunteer at school and juggle childcare responsibilities with my husband.  In short, I hear and feel the challenges and joys of both sides of the story. I have one friend who used to be a bank executive and has translated her professional skills into running an incredibly well-executed life and an engaging homeschooling experience for her kids.  Another friend works full time while finishing her Ph.D. and juggling the lives of three kids.  Both are phenomenal mothers, and both have a deeply rooted, purposeful sense of identity.

Being on neither side of the mommy wars, I find myself wishing that working and stay-at-home moms could engage in a dialog that would allow each of us space to grow into our new identities, instead of trying to one-up each other with the specific details of where we spend our days.

The process of growing into my new identity began for me as I intentionally prayed through, reflected on, and tried out different scenarios.  Inspired by Jan Johnson’s book Living a Purpose-full Life, I spent time discerning what God’s overarching purposes were for my life – not isolated circumstances like diaper changing or teaching, but larger purposes like caring for the tenderhearted and welcoming the stranger that I could live out in any context, in both personal and professional contexts. While I found my identity in scripture first as a child of God, I also pondered what it looked like for me to be a servant, a worker, a partner, and an advocate.

These days, I’m mostly settled into my identity as a mother.  It feels normal, right, even comfortable.  I not only love, but also like my kids.  Already, remembering those ‘adjustment years’ makes me slightly sentimental.  They were years when, like so many transitions in life, I was unsure, confused and prone to occasional freak-outs.  As I bumbled through the ups and downs of poop and nursing, tantrums and ‘do-it-myselfs’, and sleepless nights, I learned a thing or two about perseverance, sacrifice, and love that earn me the Mama badge I now wear proudly.  Paradoxically, it’s more a source of humility than pride, for I see now how I was growing up with them.  While I was raising them, they were teaching me – as much of a newbie mama as they were newborn humans – how to live.

Have you experienced the “mommy wars”? What can we do to support other women who have opted for differing lifestyles than we might choose? If you’re a mom, how has being a parent influenced your own personal and spiritual development?


Check out Jody’s blog, Between Worlds, and learn more about the “Mommy Wars” here:

Jody Fernando

Women and the Bible

The Bible and the Undoing of Patriarchy

Beth Felker Jones

Editor’s Note: On January 25, 2022, we came across this remarkable Twitter thread summarizing the…

General, Women and the Bible

Power Dynamics Between Jesus and the Canaanite Woman in Matthew 15

Harriet Reed Congdon

In a reversal of pattern, it’s the Canaanite woman, not Jesus, who delivers the final

Subscribe for our free guide

5 Pillars of Biblical Equality

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


  • Having watched, encouraged, and prayed you through the mama process I just want to tell you what a wonderful job you are doing. You are an amazing mother, I am proud of you, Mom

  • You always make me think, Jody! I miss you and our great lunch conversations.

  • Love this! So true! As a Mom who gets the best of both worlds (I work a late shift so I am a SAHM in the mornings and a working Mom in the evenings) this resonates with me! We are each called to something different and one is not better than the other. Often times it seems that no matter what the role, working or SAHM, there are pros and cons. God has created us each differently and each of our families is uniquely made and we need to do what works best for our family and ourselves, be it financially or emotionally. It so easy to compare or be jealous of what someone else has or to lessen the hardships of Moms who are in a different place than you or who have chosen a different path. Being a Mom can be tough, no matter what you do. Why don’t we just come along side of each other and offer words of encouragement and support rather than let comparison steal our joy?! God has placed these kids in our care and has entrusted us with their tiny hearts that are so easily molded…what example are we setting for them?

    • Realizing that there are pros and cons to each decision has been significant for me in making my peace with how I do motherhood. No arrangement is entirely perfect, and living with this tension is important. It seems to me that the struggle on the stay-at-home mom side is toward appearing perfect and the struggle on the in-the-office side is feeling guilty. Neither tendency is healthy for us or our kids, and each side has its pitfalls. You’re so right – the sooner we recognize that motherhood is hard and that we will all fail our kids in some way or another, the quicker we actually start embracing the time we have with them and doing the real parenting.

  • I am a couple of decades older than you are and so remember those mixed feelings when raising tiny children. I had three in 4.5 years and chose to stay at home to raise them. Looking back, I’m glad I had the freedom to make that choice. But in the middle of it? I felt lost and lonely a lot of the time. I adored my kids and I found ways to make life interesting and challenging, but I’m not sure what I would choose if I had a do-over. I’m just glad that we CAN choose and pray that as Christian women, we will not shoot one another with our words or opinions when we choose differently from one another. Thanks for this thoughtful essay, Jody.

    • Thanks for sharing! I love hearing from women who have made it all the way to the other end of motherhood, though some seem to forget the hard parts occasionally. It’s helpful to hear that, even now, you’re not entirely certain about every decision you made.

Comments are closed.

Scroll to Top